Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Laura's avatar

Dear Rayne,

I am surprised to find this email in my inbox given that I found you through AutoCrit. I certainly have no objection to a competition for people who don't want to use AI, despite being baffled how you will tell whether someone has used an AI prompt to inspire their story. There are plenty of good reasons not to use AI, especially as it can be considered unethical and supporting theft from creators. However, I am shocked at your blatant quotes in your 'funny' cartoons accusing people of not being 'real' writers just because they may have looked at something created by AI at some point in the story creation. I am even more horrified that you are telling people to quit because they find AI tools useful. AI does not take the skill or joy out of story craft. I shall be unsubscribing from your newsletter, which ironically in this format seems to have lost all the humanity that it used to have. I guess you won't be involved with AutoCrit anymore, since no one who uses it can be a 'real' writer.

From

A writer who loves writing and enjoys honing my craft with multiple tools and human feedback

Expand full comment
Jessie Winterspring's avatar

I've been a long time reader of your books thanks to your black cat haha (probably over 15 years now. I've posted reviewed of my favorites some too busy reading next to review) and I'm finally debuting (again) in this pen name. And those editing and writing advice is still with me. I hope I can get the physical copies soon and hopefully have it signed if I ever meet you.

Thanks for hard support on true human talent. I decided to stopped joining NaNoWriMo this years for this reason. However, I'm not against AI in general. I'M AGAINST AI-GENERATED content, which I think is also what you meant in this letter and all the cartoons.

This will be quite a challenge for me because I'm not a gothic writer, but I want to join the contest. Goodluck me! Haha

Expand full comment
2 more comments...

No posts